Embassy News
 Arts & Living
 Travel & Hotel
 Medical Tourism New
 Letters to Editor
 Photo Gallery
 News Media Link
 TV Schedule Link
 News English
 Hospitals & Clinics
 Flea Market
 Moving & Packaging
 Religious Service
 Korean Classes
 Korean Weather
 Real Estate
 Home Stay
 Room Mate
 English Teaching
 Job Offered/Wanted
 Hotel Lounge
 Foreign Exchanges
 Korean Stock
 Business Center
 PR & Ads
 Arts & Performances
 Restaurants & Bars
 Tour & Travel
 Shopping Guide
 Foreign Missions
 Community Groups
 Foreign Workers
 Useful Services
 ST Banner Exchange
  Medical Tourism
Overcoming Roadblocks in Translating Evidence-Based Healthcare into Public Health Gains
Special Contribution
By Shobha Shukla
Dr. Prathap Tharyan

Commendable progress has been made in the South Asian region to advance evidence-based healthcare and let evidence inform policy and programmes at different levels. But there have been roadblocks too that are slowing down the progress.

Citizen News Service (CNS) spoke with Dr Prathap Tharyan, Director, South Asian Cochrane Network and Centre, who has led from the front on the cause of evidence-based healthcare in this region, and globally. Dr Tharyan is also the co-chair of the 22nd Cochrane Colloquium, which is taking place for the first-time ever in the South Asian region in Hyderabad, India.

When we read about the research study outcomes, it is important to know reliably how strong (or weak) the evidence is. Dr Tharyan said: "Cochrane has developed the ability over the years to help people unwrap a body of research, and not just one study on a topic. It looks at all the studies on a particular topic to cull out all the important outcomes that are really going to make a difference to people. Because by the time a research is done and outcomes are obtained by researchers or by people with vested interests, and while they may show statistical significance (X is better than Y and this difference is not by chance) it may not prove to be a very important study for the people.

Cochrane is trying to look at what are the important outcomes and differences regarding a particular topic clinically."Dr Tharyan's experience shows that people from diverse range of sectors do want evidence to help them take right decisions. "People actually want to know how to use evidence; they just need to be facilitated in this process. It is not that they are not inherently interested, it is just that they may not know how to interpret it, and so they tend to depend on some people's opinions. So given a sustained collaborative approach things will change."

Money crunch: Despite having evidence, governments often struggle to act because of lack of financial resources. "Countries like India where resources are constrained and the government is not able to put the entire money in health alone, we are able to meet only a fraction of the healthcare needs of the population" said Dr Tharyan. Profit before people: Dr Tharyan added: "We know that a majority of the healthcare needs are met through private sources with people spending money out of their own pocket. Unfortunately the private healthcare services in India are of variable quality—some are very good while others are not. This unregulated private health sector flourishes because it believes in profit.

So we are fighting the big challenge of a difference in ideology, whereas ideology should be that healthcare is governed by reasonably good evidence that something works or does not work. For most people in the healthcare industry the bottom line is their bank balance. So very often patients are subjected to unnecessary investigations costing a lot of money and those who want to practice evidence based medicines are considered to be old fashioned. So what the majority believes has become the norm, even though it is based on false premises. Standards of healthcare in the country are now corporate hospitals prescribing unnecessary diagnostic tests that are not required. Medical profession is not providing leadership and there are not many people in it who are trying to change the system for better. It is not taking responsibility for its acts. Majority of young doctors follow their own models who unfortunately are doing the wrong things. This Colloquium is about giving at least some young people a vision of what is possible if we all work together. This is a rare opportunity to interact with people who are fighting for evidence based treatment and diagnostics."

Dr Tharyan has hit the nail right on its head, again. After a strong and clear negative advisory from the World Health Organization (WHO) on use of blood serological tests for diagnosis of active TB disease, and the Indian government's potentially game-changing decision to ban serology tests for TB diagnosis in June 2012 'with immediate effect', its use is still prevalent in the private sector despite mounting evidence against it. This is just one example which underlines how malpractices in private sector continue to negatively impact public health, despite overwhelming strong evidence and policy frameworks.

According to the Medical Council of India (MCI), the number of private medical colleges (215 private medical colleges with 25070 MBBS seats) is more than the government public medical colleges (183 government medical colleges with 24860 MBBS seats). It is common knowledge that the medical education costs an astronomical amount of money in private medical colleges compared to heavily subsidized medical schooling in public government medical colleges. Dr Tharyan said: "These days doctors have to spend a lot of money on their education (in private medical colleges). There is subsidised healthcare and subsidised medical education in government setup but not so in private setup."

Despite criticism of pharmaceutical companies funding medical conferences, the trend is not declining. But all is not that dark and we do see light: 22nd Cochrane Colloquium has deliberately not received even a single penny from any pharmaceutical company or manufacturer of medical supplies, a golden trend-setting example for medical community. The conflict of interest has to be recognized and pharmaceutical companies' public relation exercises in the form of gifts, sponsorships or incentives to medical community must not only be de-normalized but also exposed.

The very fact that the South Asian region is hosting its first-ever Cochrane Colloquium in Hyderabad sends a very promising signal to evidence-based healthcare in the region, and globally. "This meet is a small drop in the ocean, but it is large enough to create a ripple. It has been 10 years since we decided to be a network (SACNC) here in India," he said.

'Opening the gates' of Cochrane Library in India

The goal of evidence-based healthcare becomes more achievable when people from a range of sectors can have free access to quality and reliable evidence. Thanks to the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) and persistent advocacy done by the South Asian Cochrane Network and Centre (SACNC) housed in Christian Medical College (CMC) Vellore among others, the Cochrane Library is free and open to all in India.

But did 'opening the gates' to this goldmine repository of evidence (The Cochrane Library) had a positive outcome in terms of increase in use of evidence for decision-making? Dr Tharyan shared that: "It has made a big difference. Usage of Cochrane library has grown exponentially from something like 9000 reviews being downloaded to more than a 100,000 downloads today. People are reading/ accessing it more and more. Also a lot many Cochrane users are becoming Cochrane authors and the kind of questions they are asking are relevant to our region in terms of public health and management of diseases in our contexts."

Improving science and ethics

Dr Tharyan further shared: "Overseas people are using us as partners as we are able to contextualize the problems. Also it is increasingly being used in teaching medical students. So the way they are thinking about medicine is changing. Apart from reviewing, we at Cochrane are also doing original research in identifying gaps and finding evidence. While doing research we are trying to improve the quality of research—both the science as well as the ethics. As a direct result of my involvement with Cochrane, I was invited to join WHO International Clinical Trial Registry Bank because of which I met the then Director General of ICMR and he asked me to help do the Indian registry. This registry has a vision and a mission.

The mission has been complied with. The vision is to use it to improve the quality of our research. This registry has a template that actually facilitates good research. Methods of doing a good trial are clearly disclosed. We have done a study looking at the protocols registered in our controlled trials registry and the publications. Hopefully we will change the trajectory of primary research."Despite WHO recommendation to use a specific drug combination (Primaquine plus Chloroquine) for 14 days in cases of malaria vivax, countries such as India, Sri Lanka and Pakistan were then providing the medication for 5 days. Dr Tharyan and the Cochrane team responded to this gap. They did a Cochrane review which showed that 14 days of therapy (Primaquine and Chloraquine) was "significantly better" than 5 days of therapy with either Chloroquine alone or with the combination of Primaquine and Chloraquine.

Dr Tharyan's team at Cochrane shared this strong evidence with ICMR and are trying to advocate for policy change with the government in the wake of this evidence since last three years. But drug pricing is a barrier perhaps, as 14 days therapy will cost more than 5 days therapy. "The price of drug has to come down too. Countries like India have competing health priorities and have very limited money, so they deserve low priced medicines more than anyone else" argued Dr Tharyan.

Increased recognition to evidence-based healthcare

ICMR is now commissioning systematic reviews. "They pay for it too and I am part of the panel that calls for systematic reviews in child health. We are working with the policy-makers themselves and they understand the importance of Cochrane work," said Dr Tharyan.

Evidence informs healthcare but does not dictate

Framing of policies can be done with help of researchers but implementation is not part of researchers' work and mandate. "Evidence informs healthcare but it does not dictate. Our job as researchers is to summarize evidences in a truthful manner, abstract them in a form that policy makers can understand and then discuss with them if it can or cannot be implemented. They may say it is good but we cannot use it for certain reasons. This is fair enough. But if they do not know that evidence exists and they do something else then that is really serious. Our job is to be knowledge brokers" said Dr Tharyan.

Breaking silos

Different stakeholders for achieving the formidable goal of sustainable development and health justice will perhaps not deny using evidence-based approaches in their own roles and contexts. Researchers who produce good evidence to inform health policy need pragmatic mechanisms to influence health policy and programming at all levels. Researchers, medical and healthcare workers, politicians, relief and aid workers, media and communication workers, philanthropists, development planners, and all other sectors must not close their eyes to good evidence that is relevant to their contexts. As goes the Chinese proverb: "The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago. The second best time is now."

Related Articles
    Shooting Our Own Foot: Misuse of Medicines Is ...
    When Will We Start Caring for Our Caregivers?
    Ending TB One Barangay at a Time
    Are We Putting Money Where the Mouth Is to ...
    Early and Accurate TB Diagnosis Is the Gateway ...
    Long Walk to Transgender Rights and Gender ...
    Strong Local Actions Are Pivotal to Reduce ...
    The Head Must Follow What the Hand Writes
    Ending Tobacco Smoking Is Bedrock for ...
    Asia Pacific Has over 6.7 Million New TB Cases
    Will Shorter, Safer and More Effective TB ...
    Whither Women's Reproductive Health in Asia ...
    Build the World We Want: Healthy Future for All
    New TB Treatment Breakthroughs Must Reach the ...
    How Will Children Living with HIV Grow Up ...
    Writing Is on the Wall: Pictorial Health ...
    Failing on the Basics: Are We Able to Break ...
    A Bouquet of Novel Compounds: New Treatment ...
    One Size Does Not Fit All: Expanding the ...
    Tale of Two Pandemics: Follow the Science and ...
    Governments Must Adopt a Strong Political ...
    What Is the Ring?
    Disability Is Not Limited to the Body, It Is ...
    Accelerating Progress on Sexual & Reproductive ...
    Stop This Shaming of Menstruation
    Complacency Breeds Failure: Consolidate ...
    For Age Is Opportunity No Less Than Youth ...
    New Study Pegs the Number of TB Cases in India ...
    Self-stigma: Let Us Do More Than Just "Ttalk ...
    We Cannot Eliminate TB If We Leave Children ...
    MDR-TB Treatment Rgimen: Short Indeed Is ...
    A Plain Face Can Take the Sheen Out of Deadly ...
    Strike at the Root of the Problem to Kill TB
    Antibiotic Use Is Driving Antibiotic Resistance
    Big Push for Transgender and Hijra Welfare
    Where There Is a Will There Is a Way: Teeja ...
    Lung Cancer: Difficult to Diagnose, Difficult ...
    Long Road to Justice: Human Rights of Female ...
    Medical Malpractices: Is There Light at the ...
    Management of Respiratory Diseases beyond ...
    Gender Justice to Be at the Heart of ...
    Connecting the Dots: Tobacco Use, Diabetes, ...
    It Is Time To Control Asthma
    Call for No More New HIV Infected Children
    Smoking Goes Electronic
    Break the Silence around Cancer
    How Can You Treat Your Illness Unless You Take ...
    Asthma Medicines Still Unaffordable for Many
    New Technique to Prevent Diabetic Lower-Limb ...
    Cycle Beads: The Bead String for Family ...
    Beware: All Forms of Tobacco Are Harmful!
    Mother's Milk Is the Best Nutrition for the ...
    Where Is The TB Quilt, Nay Mask?
    Hello, This Is Nature’s Call From Garbage ...
    Tuberculosis: Ugly Scar on Beautiful Childhood
    Towards A More Enabling Environment for ...
    What’s Cooking in Kitchen: Peace or Conflict?
    Feed Your Child Well: Prevent Pneumonia
    Costly Medicines Mean Debt or Death for People ...
    AIDS Epidemic at a Critical Juncture in ...
    Watch Your Tongue Mr. Minister!
    Free Trade Agreements: A Threat To People's ...
    In The Pursuit Of Healthy Happiness
    Empowering Rural Women
    Say Yes To Life: Say No To Tobacco
    Homophobia Is A Human Rights Issue
    Viva La Woman Power
    Rubbish Rubbish Food and Embrace Healthy ...
    Of Music and Divinity
    Wake Up Call on Childhood Obesity after Years ...
    A New Hope of Life for Our Ailing Education ...
    Reminiscences of Egypt
    Do Not Break the Nucleus
    Whispers of Sanity in the Frenzy of Madness
    Tobacco Cessation Can Piggy-back Ride on ...
    In The Spirit Of Freedom (from Tobacco)
    World Conference on Tobacco or Health to ...
    Requiem for Purity
    Rhapsody 2008 -- a Symphony of Different ...
    'Diabetes Doctor Is at Your Doorstep' in ...
    Activists Decry India's Deferment of Pictorial ...
    South-East Asian Diabetes Summit to Open Up in ...
    Special on Universal Children's Day
    The Wrath Of God
    World Food Scarcity and the Challenges of ...
    Victim of Terrorism -- the Common Man
    Teachers' Day: The Sacrificial Goat
    Hiroshima Day: Let Us Worship Peace and Shun ...
    Whither the Innocence of Childhood?
    Food for Thought -- on World Food Day
    Love Is the Missing Link in War-on-Terror
    Irom Sharmila: The Iron Lady
    India Poised And Shining
    Is It Just Another Day in Life of Indian Woman?
    He Has His Cake and Eats It Too
    To Be Young, to Be Married, and to Be in India
    The Mad Mad World of Ads

Other Articles by Shobha Shukla
    Shooting Our Own Foot: Misuse of Medicines ...
    Early and Accurate TB Diagnosis Is the ...
    Strong Local Actions Are Pivotal to Reduce ...
    The Head Must Follow What the Hand Writes
    Ending Tobacco Smoking Is Bedrock for ...

Ms. Shobha Shukla has been teaching Physics at India's noted Loreto Convent, and has written for The Hindustan Times and Women's Era in the past. She serves as Editor of Citizen News Service (CNS). She can be contacted at






The Seoul Times, Shinheung-ro 36ga-gil 24-4, Yongsan-gu, Seoul, Korea 04337 (ZC)
Office: 82-10-6606-6188 Publisher & Editor: Joseph Joh
Copyrights 2000 The Seoul Times Company  ST Banner Exchange