News
 International
   Global Views
   Asia-Pacific
   America
   Europe
   Middle East & Africa
 National
 Embassy News
 Arts & Living
 Business
 Travel & Hotel
 Medical Tourism New
 Taekwondo
 Media
 Letters to Editor
 Photo Gallery
 Cartoons/Comics/Humor
 News Media Link
 TV Schedule Link
 News English
 Life
 Hospitals & Clinics
 Flea Market
 Moving & Packaging
 Religious Service
 Korean Classes
 Korean Weather
 Housing
 Real Estate
 Home Stay
 Room Mate
 Job
 English Teaching
 Translation/Writing
 Job Offered/Wanted
 Business
 Hotel Lounge
 Foreign Exchanges
 Korean Stock
 Business Center
 PR & Ads
 Entertainment
 Arts & Performances
 Restaurants & Bars
 Tour & Travel
 Shopping Guide
 Community
 Foreign Missions
 Community Groups
 PenPal/Friendship
 Volunteers
 Foreign Workers
 Useful Services
 ST Banner Exchange
  Asia-Pacific
Letter from India
Will Independent Commission Increase Judicial Accountability?
By Bobby Ramakant
Asia Correspondent
Mid Day

The recent case of Justice Sabharwal and the sentencing of four Mid Day journalists again brought to the fore the problem of the lack of accountability of the higher judiciary in the country. "We have today, a judiciary with enormous powers, but virtually no accountability" said senior Supreme Court advocate Prashant Bhushan, on behalf of Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms (CJAR) committee which is patronized by Justice VR Krishna Iyer, Justice PB Sawant, Justice H Suresh, Shri Shanti Bhushan, Shri Prabhash Joshi, and Arundhati Roy among others.

With the failure of the impeachment system, no mechanism has been put in place for investigating and taking action against judicial misconduct. "The problem is compounded by the use of contempt power which is deterring even exposure of judicial misconduct" said Dr Sandeep Pandey, Magsaysay Awardee (2002) and National Convener of NAPM (National Alliance of People's Movements).

An Independent National Judicial Commission might be able to regulate the power of contempt of the Judiciary. CJAR is dedicated to build strong public opinion to force Parliament and the Government to bring the required amendments to the Constitution and the laws for an independent judicial commission.

The judiciary in the country today is not only the arbiter of disputes between citizens, between citizens and the State, between States and the Union, it also in purported exercise of powers to enforce fundamental rights, directs the governments to close down industries, commercial establishments, demolish jhuggis, remove hawkers and rickshaw pullers from the streets, prohibits strikes and bandhs etc. In short, it has come to be the most powerful institution of the State.

Every other institution of the State is accountable to the anti-corruption agencies, and to the judiciary which has the power of judicial review over every executive and legislative action. Moreover, the political executive is accountable to the legislature and the legislature is democratically accountable to the people-that at least is the theory of our constitutional scheme.

However, when it comes to the judiciary, we find that it is neither democratically accountable to the people, nor to any other institution. The only recourse against a judge committing judicial misconduct is impeachment, which has been found to be a totally impractical remedy. To initiate the impeachment process one needs the signatures of 100 Lok Sabha or 50 Rajya Sabha MPs. This one cannot secure unless two conditions are satisfied. First, one must have conclusive documentary evidence of very serious misconduct against a judge. And second, the evidence and the charges must have been publicized, such that it has assumed the proportions of a public scandal. Till that happens, there are few MPs who are willing to put their signatures on an impeachment motion. Most MPs or their parties have cases in court, and nobody wants to invite the wrath of the judiciary.

The media is unwilling to publicise the charges against judges (even when they have documentary evidence to back the charges) because of the fear of contempt of Court which constantly hangs as a sword over their necks.

Mid Day had carried a series of articles in May and June 2007 showing how Justice Sabharwal passed the orders of sealing commercial properties in residential areas in Delhi after his sons had got into partnerships with at least two of the leading shopping mall and commercial complex developers of Delhi. These orders stood to directly benefit his sons and their partners by pushing the sealed shops and offices to shopping malls and commercial complexes and thus driving up their prices.

Mid Day published much of the documentary evidence in support of this huge story exposing what appeared to be a scandalous conspiracy at the Apex of the judiciary.

Yet neither any other media organization, nor any judicial, executive nor legislative authority acted upon these news stories.

Thereafter, on 3 August 2007, CJAR released a detailed charge-sheet containing as many as 7 serious charges against Justice Sabharwal, each backed with documentary evidence. Tehelka and Karan Thapar carried major stories on it. The story however hit the headlines in the mainstream media only after the conviction of 4 Mid Day journalists by the Delhi High Court for contempt.

If someone has evidence of corruption by a judge, there is not much that can be done. It cannot be exposed because of the fear of contempt, in the absence of which, even impeachment is a non-starter. FIR cannot be registered against the judge under the prevention of Corruption Act, because of an embargo created by the Supreme Court in 1991 by means of a judgement where they held that no judge can be subjected to a criminal investigation without the prior written consent of the Chief Justice of India. In the 16 years since that judgement, not even a single FIR has been registered against a sitting judge. To top it all, the recent attempt by the judiciary to insulate themselves from the Right to Information Act, has made it further difficult.

The Mid Day journalists were convicted despite their offering to prove the truth of all their allegations. The High Court held that the truth of the allegations was irrelevant since they had brought the entire judiciary into disrepute.

All this underlines the need to do away with this jurisdiction of punishing for "scandalizing the court or lowering the authority of the court."

There is a compelling need to have a totally independent constitutional body called the National Judicial Commission which will have the power to investigate charges against judges and take action against them, feels CJAR.



Related Articles
    Do It Right the First Time, Every Time!
    Keeping Workforce Healthy Is Also a Smart ...
    Should Asia Pacific Lead World with Robust ...
    Will Post-2015 Development Agenda Integrate ...
    Nepal Leading Tobacco Control in S. Asia: Will ...
    Regular HIV Prevention Counselling Reduces ...
    Strong Tobacco Taxation Policy Adopted despite ...
    Biggest Killer of Kids Under 5 Is Pneumonia
    Scaling Up Natural Fertility Awareness Methods ...
    Should Asthma Control Us or We Control Asthma?
    Coordinated Approach Needed to Overcome ...
    Lung Health Needs Attention
    Should Tuberculosis (TB)-Preventive Therapy ...
    Responding to TB, HIV, COPD and Tobacco ...
    "Good Health Is India's Basic Need": Easier ...
    Int'l Day Against Drug Abuse, Illicit ...
    World Now in Early Days of 2009 Influenza ...
    One-Third Preventable Deaths Can Be Averted by ...
    Politics: Allocation of Resources
    If G20 Agrees, Health Financing Might Come ...
    Neglect of Tuberculosis Control among ...
    Is It Ethical to Provide TB Treatment without ...
    Youth against Cross-border Tobacco Advertising ...
    Vitamin A Supplements Reduces Child Mortality ...
    Mayawati Ji, Why Did We Get Bulldozers Instead ...
    How Will the World Begin to See TB Care as a ...
    Will recession impede TB care and control?
    Kala Azar Patients Lack Adequate Diagnosis and ...
    Further Dilution of Pictorial Tobacco Warnings ...
    Village Community Radio Will Give Voice to ...
    Citizens of India-Pakistan Stand Up for Peace
    Another Blow to Enforcement of Tobacco Control ...
    Addressing HIV and IDU Issues Vital for TB ...
    Effective Tobacco Control Policies in Nepal ...
    Countries Unite against Tobacco Industry Abuse
    India Agrees That Tobacco Industry Puts ...
    National Partnership for TB Care and Control ...
    Need to Refrain from Communal Politics in India
    India Embraces Smoke-free Policies on ...
    3rd Global Tobacco Treaty Action Guide 2008 ...
    Uphold Public Health over Corporate Interests
    Bringing Diabetes to Light
    Andhra Pradesh Should Gear Up to Enforce ...
    Pictorial Warnings on Tobacco Products in ...
    HDN and the International HIV/AIDS Alliance ...
    'We Reject Indo-US Nuclear Deal' Campaign ...
    Help Aamir Khan to Keep Promises and Quit ...
    Indian Court Serves Notice to Amitabh Bachchan ...
    NAPM Opposes the Indo-US Nuclear Deal
    Overcoming State Suppression, Prof. Agarwal ...
    10-Day Fast in Support of Dr. Binayak Sen ...
    Will South Korea Reaffirm Commitment to TB/HIV ...
    Activists to Fast for 10 Days Demanding ...
    Enforce Existing Tobacco Control Legislations ...
    Scaling Up of MPOWER Tobacco Control ...
    Kanpur Land-Sharks Intimidate RTI Activist by ...
    'You Can Control Your Asthma': Dr. Nils Billo
    Will Indian Government Arrest Those Who ...
    Asthma Control Is Appalling in Most Countries
    After 1.5 Years, Right-to-Information Act ...
    Democracy Weeps in Nandigram: NHRC and NCW ...
    Enforcement of Tobacco Ban in Prisons Uphill ...
    Displaced People in India Announce a Massive ...
    Climate Change Has Implications on Public ...
    Who Will Pay US$ 80 Billion to Halve the No. ...
    Can South Korea Stop Drug-resistant TB Too?
    Rising Tobacco Use among Women
    Japan's Obstructionist Position on Illicit ...
    Smoking in Indian Movies Gets Challenged
    'The Padyatra' Linking the Land-rights, ...
    Journalist Reporting on Under-represented ...
    Diabetes Wake-up Call after Years of Neglect ...
    Stop Dow Recruitment in IIT Chennai
    Round-the-clock Burma Vigil in Parliament ...
    Burma Unifies People's Voices in North-East ...
    Mounting Public Pessure against Dams in ...
    India Ranks 72 in 180 Nations on Corruption ...
    Strengthen Health Systems to Control Dengue: ...
    Young Professionals in US Bring Agri-issues ...
    Mayawati Government to Expedite Justice in ...
    Court Reprimands MP Government for Arresting ...
    News of Three Deaths at IIT Kanpur Confirmed
    Anti-AFSPA Protestors Demand "Free Burma and ...
    Fate of 25,000 Families Hinge on Sept. 20 NCA ...
    IHP Launched to Strengthen Health Systems
    India's Under-nutrition Levels among Highest
    After 20 Years, RTI Is Another Blow to ...
    Public Pressure Mounts against Arrest of ...
    Dhaka Univ. Faculty, Students Beaten Up, ...
    Tobacco Industry Succeeds in Diluting Indian ...
    Activists Oppose the Indo-US Nuclear Deal
    Women Farmers Fast against Reliance ...
    Pepsi to Print 'Public Water Source' on Labels
    Youth Appeal to UN to Prioritise Health
    UN Mid-Point Progress Report on Development ...
    148 Nations Meet as Parties to Global Tobacco ...
    Alert to Protect Global Tobacco Treaty before ...
    Patil in for President's Race Not Only because ...
    Hashimpura Survivors Find Hope in RTI Act
    Hyderabad Blast: Wake Up Call for Secular India
    Health Ministry Alert on Iron-Deficiency ...
    Medical Students Need to Quit Tobacco First
    Integrate Tobacco Cessation in Healthcare ...
    1st Time Indians Get 2007 Human Rights Prize
    Responding to Diverse HIV Healthcare Needs
    Why Should S. Korea Enforce Tobacco Treaty?
    34 Cases of Avian Influenza Found in Egypt
    With Inadequate Cessation Services, What Will ...
    Another Death of Pregnant Woman with HIV Is ...
    Don't Forget The Rise in Violence Against ...
    A Ray of Hope for Medical University Teaching
    Alarm Bells Sound in Nandigram for Indian ...
    Activists Challenge Corporate Control of Water ...
    Vietnam's TB Programs Face New Challenges
    Neglect of Hepatitis C Leaves People with HIV ...
    Tobacco Industries Disregard Nepal's ...
    Link between Tobacco Use and Films
    Integration of TB and HIV Services Urgently ...
    More of the Same Will Brew Drug Resistance
    Is a Priority, Says Indian President Kalam
    Head Injuries Soar Unabatedly: Prof. Rama Kant
    Groundwater Belongs to People, Not to Firms
    Tobacco Shown in Movies Influences Children
    Water Is a Fundamental Human Right
    Global Tobacco Treaty Should Be Implemented
    Founder of Surgical Oncology in India Dies
    HIV Prevention Must Address Women' Needs
    Staying Alive with HIV

Other Articles by Bobby Ramakant
     Do It Right the First Time, Every Time!
     Keeping Workforce Healthy Is Also a Smart ...
     Should Asia Pacific Lead World with Robust ...
     Will Post-2015 Development Agenda Integrate ...
     Nepal Leading Tobacco Control in S. Asia: ...


Bobby Ramakant, who serves as The Seoul Times' Asia correspondent, is a member of NATT, Network for Accountability of Tobacco Transnationals, and edits Weekly MONiTOR series, reporting violations of tobacco control policies as a senior public health and development journalist. He writes for newspapers in 11 countries and can be reached at bobbyramakant@yahoo.com)

 

back

 

 

 

The Seoul Times Shinheungro 25-gil 2-6 Yongsan-gu, Seoul, Korea 04337 (ZC)
Office: 02-555-6188 Email:seoultimes@gmail.com
Copyrights 2000 The Seoul Times Company  ST Banner Exchange